Owning apartments is often portrayed as the ultimate passive-income dream—but as any advisor at Ellsbury Commercial Group will tell you, the performance of a multifamily asset lives and dies by its management. Whether you self-manage, hire a third-party firm, or combine both, your management strategy influences everything: leasing velocity, resident experience, operating expenses, compliance, lender confidence, exit value, and ultimately, risk.
What follows is a candid, in-the-trenches guide from the perspective of a commercial real estate broker and advisor at Ellsbury. It explores how to approach self-management, how to select and supervise a third-party manager, and how to build a management framework that protects NOI while compounding long-term value.
Why Management Matters More Than Almost Anything Else
Management is the operating system of your property. The best location, asset vintage, or renovation plan can all be undone by poor execution. Conversely, an average property with excellent management will often outperform. Here’s why:
Revenue control: Pricing, concessions, renewals, and marketing mix are all management levers. Even a 1–2% lift in economic occupancy or a 50-bps improvement in renewal rates can translate into six- or seven-figure gains depending on the cap rate.
Expense discipline: Preventive maintenance, vendor bidding, bulk purchasing, and utility optimization directly shape your margins.
Risk management: Compliance, safety, fair housing, and resident relations mitigate legal exposure and turnover—silent killers of cash flow.
Option 1: Self-Management (SM) — Education Through Exposure
Self-management offers unmatched hands-on experience. It puts you directly in the trenches, where you learn leasing, maintenance, resident relations, budgeting, and reporting by doing. That operational literacy will later make you a sharper asset manager, even if you outsource down the line.
Advantages
-
Mastery of your own P&L: No information gap—you see issues early and can pivot fast.
-
Culture control: You hire the onsite team and define service standards.
-
Cost transparency: No markup on management fees; you decide where to invest or DIY.
Realities (No, It’s Not Passive)
-
Time-intensive: Expect to be on call. Leasing surges, turn season, and make-readies don’t run on your schedule.
-
Regulatory burden: Fair housing, habitability, licensing, and trust accounting mistakes can be costly.
-
People operations: Recruiting, training, and performance management fall squarely on you.
Self-Management Playbook (How to Do It Well)
Structure
-
Create an Asset Management Calendar: weekly leasing review, weekly maintenance huddle, monthly financial close, quarterly CapEx walk.
-
Define RACI (Responsible/Accountable/Consulted/Informed) across ownership, onsite staff, maintenance, and vendors.
Leasing Engine
-
Track lead-to-lease funnel: impressions → leads → showings → applications → approvals → move-ins.
-
Use disciplined pricing reviews—update weekly based on traffic, seasonality, and comps.
Maintenance System
-
Work-order SLA: emergency <4 hrs, urgent <24 hrs, routine <72 hrs.
-
PM schedule: HVAC filters quarterly, pest control monthly, roof/lighting quarterly, fire-life-safety per code.
Accounting & Controls
-
Separate operating and deposit accounts; reconcile monthly.
-
Apply a three-bid rule for non-emergency spends above $2,500.
Resident Experience
-
New-resident orientation, 72-hour move-in QC call, renewal offers at day 120.
-
Track satisfaction quarterly (NPS or simple survey).
Technology Stack (examples)
Property management system (PMS), digital make-ready board, maintenance app, AI or call-center overflow, revenue management, utility billing.
Key Self-Management KPIs
Economic occupancy, loss-to-lease, delinquency, vacancy days, turn time, work-order completion time, renewal rate, marketing cost per lease, NOI margin.
When It Makes Sense
-
Early in your portfolio, to build operational chops.
-
When the asset is near your home base.
-
When you can dedicate 6–18 months for stabilization.
Option 2: Third-Party Management (TPM) — Leverage With Oversight
A strong third-party manager brings people, process, and platform from day one—but you must still manage the manager. Without oversight, even good assets can erode. We’ve seen it: deferred maintenance, unvetted vendors, compliance issues, and sloppy reporting. The cure is rigorous diligence upfront and structured accountability afterward.
What a Good TPM Provides
-
Experienced onsite staff and bench coverage.
-
Proven SOPs for leasing, collections, and maintenance.
-
Vendor and marketing buying power.
-
Compliance and reporting aligned with lenders and ownership.
Fee Structures to Understand
Base fee (percentage of collected revenue), leasing/renewal fees, maintenance markups, CapEx management fees, and ancillary splits (pets, RUBS, parking).
Demand transparency: full fee schedule, markup disclosure, and written approval thresholds for pass-throughs.
Red Flags (Real-World Lessons)
-
Late or error-filled financials.
-
Trust accounts not reconciling to bank statements.
-
Vendor invoices lacking documentation.
-
Chronic unit-turn delays or high evictions.
-
Static pricing in dynamic markets.
-
High staff turnover without a recruiting plan.
Due Diligence Checklist for Hiring a TPM
References: Call three current and one former client—ask how the firm handles mistakes.
Portfolio fit: Match asset type, class, and unit count.
Team coverage: Identify your regional manager and backup.
Processes: Review leasing, delinquency, eviction, and turn protocols.
Controls: Examine bank rec cadence, procurement, insurance, and fair housing training.
Technology: Confirm data ownership and export rights.
Reporting: Request sample owner reports with GL, variance notes, AR/AP detail, and KPIs.
Protective Contract Terms
Termination for cause/convenience, key-person rights, spending approval limits, SLA benchmarks, data ownership, transition support, and audit rights.
The Hybrid Model — The Best of Both Worlds
Many operators combine owner-led asset management with a TPM. You keep control of strategy while outsourcing execution.
Owner Focus (Asset Management)
-
Set revenue strategy, budgets, and CapEx plan.
-
Approve pricing and marketing mix.
-
Review weekly KPIs.
-
Lead monthly and quarterly reviews.
TPM Focus (Property Management)
-
Execute leasing, collections, service, and resident relations.
-
Maintain compliance and vendor coordination.
Cadence That Works
-
Weekly 30–45-min call: traffic, pricing, delinquency, make-readies, staffing.
-
Monthly financial review: GL, variances, bank recs, NOI vs. budget.
-
Quarterly walk: CapEx and risk check-ins.
KPIs That Predict Outcomes
Track these weekly or monthly:
Leasing & Revenue: traffic-to-lease conversion, effective vs. market rent, loss-to-lease, concessions %, economic occupancy, renewal rate, rent change on renewals.
Operations & Maintenance: work-order volume, completion time, turn cycle, turn cost vs. budget, inspection cadence.
Financial Health: AR aging, delinquency, expense variance, utility cost/unit, NOI margin, DSCR.
Resident Experience: satisfaction/NPS, response times, incident logs, renewal intent surveys.
Case Snapshots (Names Changed)
Case A: The “Set It and Forget It” Fiasco
An absentee owner relied entirely on their TPM. Within six months, delinquency doubled, turns lagged, and vendor markups ballooned. NOI fell 12%, and the lender flagged late reports. After tighter oversight and weekly reviews, NOI recovered in two quarters.
Lesson: You must manage the management.
Case B: Self-Management Bootcamp
A local investor self-managed a 24-unit C-class for 18 months, optimizing operations and renegotiating vendors. NOI rose 21%. They later transitioned to TPM, retaining their KPI discipline.
Lesson: Self-management can be a powerful training ground.
Case C: Hybrid Discipline
A 120-unit value-add paired owner-led asset management with a TPM. Regular KPI reviews caught roof issues early—saving six figures.
Lesson: Cadence + visibility prevent expensive surprises.
Risk Controls That Separate Pros from Amateurs
-
Trust accounting: Monthly reconciliations with owner sign-off.
-
Vendor vetting: COIs, W-9s, background checks, three-bid rule.
-
Compliance calendar: Fair housing refreshers, safety drills, inspections.
-
Incident protocol: Clear reporting process for injuries, crimes, floods, mold.
-
CapEx governance: Defined scope, bid, lien waiver, and retainage process.
Your First 90 Days With a New TPM
Days 0–15: Kickoff, transitions, inspections, and risk log.
Days 16–45: Pricing/marketing audit, collections plan, maintenance calendar.
Days 46–90: First full close with KPIs, renewal strategy, and ownership walk.
Questions to Ask a Prospective TPM
“How do you set pricing and concessions?”
“What’s your average make-ready timeline?”
“Show me your delinquency ladder.”
“How do you recruit and train staff?”
“Walk me through your vendor approval process.”
“What was your last major mistake—and how did you fix it?”
When to Fire Your Manager (And How)
Tripwires: Two months of bad financials, KPI slippage, compliance breaches, or recurring resident issues.
Process:
-
Issue written cure notice referencing contract SLAs.
-
Set a 30-day remediation plan with weekly check-ins.
-
If unresolved, terminate and activate transition plan (data, vendors, residents).
The Broker/Advisor’s Role — And How We Help
At Ellsbury Commercial Group, our role doesn’t end at closing. We help you:
-
Underwrite management risk during acquisition.
-
Establish oversight cadence and reporting structure.
-
Benchmark KPIs against market comps.
-
Course-correct when management performance falters.
Bottom Line
Multifamily management isn’t a line item—it’s the engine. Self-management teaches the mechanics; third-party management provides scale. Either way, your role as owner is to stay engaged: set strategy, demand transparency, and inspect what you expect. That’s how you protect downside, unlock NOI, and compound value across the hold period.
